| | | |
| May 9, 2024 | L | Evansville Otters 5 at Windy City ThunderBolts 6 | Final |
| May 10, 2024 | L | Evansville Otters 3 at Joliet Slammers 10 | Final |
| May 11, 2024 | L | Evansville Otters 2 at Joliet Slammers 3 | Final |
| May 12, 2024 | W | Evansville Otters 12 at Joliet Slammers 5 | Final |
| May 14, 2024 | | Gateway Grizzlies 0 at Evansville Otters 0 | Ppd. |
| May 15, 2024 | L | Gateway Grizzlies 5 at Evansville Otters 3 (Game 1) | Final |
| May 15, 2024 | L | Gateway Grizzlies 3 at Evansville Otters 1 (Game 2) | Final |
| May 16, 2024 | W | Gateway Grizzlies 2 at Evansville Otters 6 | Final |
| May 17, 2024 | W | Joliet Slammers 6 at Evansville Otters 10 | Final |
| May 18, 2024 | L | Joliet Slammers 2 at Evansville Otters 1 | Final |
| May 19, 2024 | W | Joliet Slammers 1 at Evansville Otters 6 | Final |
| May 21, 2024 | L | Evansville Otters 3 at Washington Wild Things 10 | Final |
| May 22, 2024 | L | Evansville Otters 1 at Washington Wild Things 2 | Final |
| May 23, 2024 | L | Evansville Otters 2 at Washington Wild Things 5 | Final |
| May 24, 2024 | W | Evansville Otters 15 at Florence Y'alls 9 | Final |
| May 25, 2024 | L | Evansville Otters 2 at Florence Y'alls 20 | Final |
| May 26, 2024 | | Evansville Otters at Florence Y'alls | Ppd. |
| May 28, 2024 | L | Washington Wild Things 5 at Evansville Otters 3 | Final |
| May 29, 2024 | L | Washington Wild Things 6 at Evansville Otters 2 | Final |
| May 30, 2024 | L | Washington Wild Things 6 at Evansville Otters 3 | Final |
| May 31, 2024 | L | Evansville Otters 2 at Gateway Grizzlies 11 | Final |
| June 1, 2024 | W | Evansville Otters 21 at Gateway Grizzlies 4 | Final |
| June 2, 2024 | L | Evansville Otters 2 at Gateway Grizzlies 16 | Final |
| June 4, 2024 | W | Lake Erie Crushers 1 at Evansville Otters 3 | Final |
| June 5, 2024 | L | Lake Erie Crushers 10 at Evansville Otters 3 | Final |
| June 6, 2024 | L | Lake Erie Crushers 8 at Evansville Otters 2 | Final |
| June 7, 2024 | W | Florence Y'alls 1 at Evansville Otters 9 | Final |
| June 8, 2024 | W | Florence Y'alls 5 at Evansville Otters 11 | Final |
| June 9, 2024 | L | Florence Y'alls 7 at Evansville Otters 1 | Final |
| June 11, 2024 | L | Evansville Otters 2 at Tri-City ValleyCats 9 | Final |
| June 12, 2024 | W | Evansville Otters 6 at Tri-City ValleyCats 1 | Final |
| June 13, 2024 | W | Evansville Otters 15 at Tri-City ValleyCats 4 | Final |
| June 14, 2024 | | Evansville Otters 0 at Sussex County Miners 0 | Ppd. |
| June 15, 2024 | L | Evansville Otters 3 at Sussex County Miners 8 | Final |
| June 16, 2024 | W | Evansville Otters 3 at Sussex County Miners 1 | Final |
| June 18, 2024 | L | Schaumburg Boomers 9 at Evansville Otters 8 | Final |
| June 19, 2024 | L | Schaumburg Boomers 4 at Evansville Otters 3 | Final |
| June 20, 2024 | W | Schaumburg Boomers 1 at Evansville Otters 10 | Final |
| June 21, 2024 | L | Windy City ThunderBolts 8 at Evansville Otters 2 | Final |
| June 22, 2024 | W | Windy City ThunderBolts 9 at Evansville Otters 10 | Final |
| June 23, 2024 | W | Windy City ThunderBolts 0 at Evansville Otters 9 | Final |
| June 25, 2024 | | Joliet Slammers 0 at Evansville Otters 0 | Ppd. |
| June 26, 2024 | L | Joliet Slammers 7 at Evansville Otters 2 | Final |
| June 27, 2024 | L | Joliet Slammers 4 at Evansville Otters 0 | Final |
| June 28, 2024 | L | Evansville Otters 1 at Windy City ThunderBolts 2 | Final |
| June 29, 2024 | L | Evansville Otters 2 at Windy City ThunderBolts 8 | Final |
| June 30, 2024 | L | Evansville Otters 1 at Windy City ThunderBolts 3 | Final |
| July 2, 2024 | W | Evansville Otters 9 at Joliet Slammers 7 | Final |
| July 3, 2024 | L | Evansville Otters 0 at Joliet Slammers 6 | Final |
| July 4, 2024 | W | Evansville Otters 6 at Joliet Slammers 2 | Final |
| July 5, 2024 | L | New England Knockouts 11 at Evansville Otters 6 | Final |
| July 6, 2024 | W | New England Knockouts 0 at Evansville Otters 5 | Final |
| July 7, 2024 | L | New England Knockouts 14 at Evansville Otters 2 | Final |
| July 9, 2024 | L | Evansville Otters 1 at Washington Wild Things 7 | Final |
| July 10, 2024 | L | Evansville Otters 4 at Washington Wild Things 5 | Final |
| July 11, 2024 | W | Evansville Otters 5 at Washington Wild Things 4 | Final |
| July 12, 2024 | L | Evansville Otters 3 at Lake Erie Crushers 7 | Final |
| July 13, 2024 | L | Evansville Otters 1 at Lake Erie Crushers 3 | Final |
| July 14, 2024 | L | Evansville Otters 5 at Lake Erie Crushers 8 | Final |
| July 19, 2024 | W | Washington Wild Things 2 at Evansville Otters 3 | Final |
| July 20, 2024 | L | Washington Wild Things 7 at Evansville Otters 2 | Final |
| July 21, 2024 | W | Washington Wild Things 3 at Evansville Otters 4 | Final |
| July 23, 2024 | W | Evansville Otters 5 at Florence Y'alls 1 (Game 1) | Final |
| July 23, 2024 | L | Evansville Otters 4 at Florence Y'alls 6 (Game 2) | Final |
| July 24, 2024 | L | Evansville Otters 6 at Florence Y'alls 9 | Final |
| July 25, 2024 | L | Evansville Otters 4 at Florence Y'alls 8 | Final |
| July 26, 2024 | W | Lake Erie Crushers 1 at Evansville Otters 9 | Final |
| July 27, 2024 | W | Lake Erie Crushers 4 at Evansville Otters 5 | Final |
| July 28, 2024 | W | Lake Erie Crushers 3 at Evansville Otters 6 | Final |
| July 30, 2024 | | Schaumburg Boomers 0 at Evansville Otters 0 | Ppd. |
| July 31, 2024 | L | Schaumburg Boomers 8 at Evansville Otters 2 | Final |
| August 1, 2024 | | Schaumburg Boomers at Evansville Otters (Game 1) | Ppd. |
| August 1, 2024 | | Schaumburg Boomers 0 at Evansville Otters 0 (Game 2) | Ppd. |
| August 2, 2024 | W | New Jersey Jackals 5 at Evansville Otters 12 | Final |
| August 3, 2024 | W | New Jersey Jackals 0 at Evansville Otters 21 | Final |
| August 4, 2024 | W | New Jersey Jackals 5 at Evansville Otters 10 | Final |
| August 6, 2024 | | Evansville Otters 0 at Lake Erie Crushers 0 | Ppd. |
| August 7, 2024 | W | Evansville Otters 7 at Lake Erie Crushers 1 (Game 1) | Final |
| August 7, 2024 | | Evansville Otters at Lake Erie Crushers (Game 2) | Ppd. |
| August 8, 2024 | L | Evansville Otters 0 at Lake Erie Crushers 9 (Game 1) | Final |
| August 8, 2024 | W | Evansville Otters 1 at Lake Erie Crushers 0 (Game 2) | Final |
| August 9, 2024 | L | Evansville Otters 3 at Gateway Grizzlies 4 | Final |
| August 10, 2024 | W | Evansville Otters 15 at Gateway Grizzlies 3 | Final |
| August 11, 2024 | L | Evansville Otters 3 at Gateway Grizzlies 5 | Final |
| August 12, 2024 | W | Evansville Otters 5 at Schaumburg Boomers 4 (Game 1) | Final |
| August 12, 2024 | L | Evansville Otters 3 at Schaumburg Boomers 5 (Game 2) | Final |
| August 13, 2024 | W | Evansville Otters 5 at Schaumburg Boomers 2 | Final |
| August 14, 2024 | L | Evansville Otters 1 at Schaumburg Boomers 13 | Final |
| August 15, 2024 | L | Evansville Otters 5 at Schaumburg Boomers 6 | Final |
| August 16, 2024 | L | Florence Y'alls 10 at Evansville Otters 0 | Final |
| August 17, 2024 | W | Florence Y'alls 5 at Evansville Otters 7 | Final |
| August 18, 2024 | W | Florence Y'alls 2 at Evansville Otters 4 | Final |
| August 20, 2024 | W | Windy City ThunderBolts 5 at Evansville Otters 6 | Final |
| August 21, 2024 | W | Windy City ThunderBolts 0 at Evansville Otters 3 | Final |
| August 22, 2024 | W | Windy City ThunderBolts 2 at Evansville Otters 4 | Final |
| August 23, 2024 | W | Gateway Grizzlies 4 at Evansville Otters 6 | Final |
| August 24, 2024 | L | Gateway Grizzlies 4 at Evansville Otters 3 | Final |
| August 25, 2024 | L | Gateway Grizzlies 7 at Evansville Otters 3 | Final |
| August 27, 2024 | L | Evansville Otters 4 at Schaumburg Boomers 10 | Final |
| August 28, 2024 | L | Evansville Otters 5 at Schaumburg Boomers 6 | Final |
| August 29, 2024 | L | Evansville Otters 8 at Schaumburg Boomers 9 | Final |
| August 30, 2024 | L | Evansville Otters 3 at Windy City ThunderBolts 5 | Final |
| August 31, 2024 | L | Evansville Otters 0 at Windy City ThunderBolts 6 | Final |
Evansville Otters Schedule
